Tuesday, April 25, 2006

Then Why...?

Leil 28 Nisan 5766

Tonight I was pleasantly surprised to find that my comment to an Arutz 7 article had been published. The article was
Arutz 7: Aviner"Spiritual Matters Not Subject to Give-and-Take"
15:15 Apr 24, '06 / 26 Nisan 5766
by Hillel Fendel

I emphasize the word "surprised." Read the article, then my comment, remember that Arutz 7 is located in Beth-El where Shlomo Aviner is co-Chief Rabbi, and you'll understand why.

Here is my comment (#19):

"Rabbenu Tzvi Yehudah ztz"l also said that one should do everything in order to delay and to prevent the giving up [even part] of the Land of Israel. Rav Melamed and Rav Lior understand this. Shlomo Aviner does not. He says one cannot refuse orders to expel Jews. He was seen chit-chatting with the Azza expulsion commander. (See photo below.) He was the one who attacked Jews who were acting on Rabbenu Tzvi Yehudah's dictate. See testimony at: www.aviner.net."

Furthermore I went to the original article, to which Hillel Fendel referred.

Machon Me'ir: 'A Bizarre Suggestion' "A Bizarre Suggestion"
Shlomo Aviner
Shabbath Hol HaMo'ed Pesach
17 Nisan 5766

I wrote to Machon Me'ir with the following question. We shall see if they bother to send me an answer.

"Shalom Aleichem. Regarding Rav Shlomo Aviner's article, I am confused. His statements here contradict his behavior in Azza this summer where he criticized and otherwise attacked Jews who were defending their homes in Eretz Yisrael. The army and police were participants in the expulsion, something which Rav Aviner clearly states is against the Hallachah. Why, then did Rav Aviner prevent and otherwise discourage residents of Azza from doing what needed to be done to defend their homes effectively, and thus prevent their fellow Jews (gov't officials, soldiers, and police) from going against a very big issur of the Torah? Thank you."

Shlomo Aviner w/Expulsion Cmdr. Uri Bar-Lev


At 18 May, 2006 10:44, Blogger Moze said...

If you think the Melameds (senior or junior) are going to do anything when their settlements are on the block, I've got a bridge in the Negev to sell you. Rav Lior, OTOH...

At 20 May, 2006 17:14, Blogger Yonathan Ya'aqobi said...

You make a fair comment. I do believe that Rav Z. Melamed does understand better than Shlomo Aviner. But, of course, everything's relative....

I agree with you about Rav Lior.

May HaShem grant him, Rav Yisrael Ariel, Rav Ya'aqov Yosef (& others?) the wisdom, strength, and courage to say what needs to be said, and to guide us.


Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home